What is tragedy? What makes a good plot? Aristotle analyses the structure of dramatic poetry with surgical precision. The concepts he introduces — catharsis, hamartia, peripeteia, anagnorisis — have shaped literary criticism for two millennia.
Start ReadingPoetry as imitation (mimesis). All art imitates human action. Aristotle classifies poetry by medium, object, and manner of imitation.
The origins of poetry. Comedy from phallic songs, tragedy from dithyrambs. The natural human love of imitation and learning.
The difference between comedy and tragedy. Comedy imitates inferior people, tragedy imitates superior ones.
The history of tragedy. Aeschylus added the second actor, Sophocles the third. The chorus diminished as dialogue grew.
Comedy and its early development. Less well-documented than tragedy because it was not taken seriously at first.
The definition of tragedy: the imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude, effecting through pity and fear the catharsis of such emotions.
The six parts of tragedy: plot, character, thought, diction, spectacle, and song. Plot is the soul of tragedy — the most important element.
The ideal plot. It must be a complete action with beginning, middle, and end. It must have a certain magnitude — neither too short nor too long.
Unity of plot. The plot should centre on a single action, not a single hero. Homer understood this; the Cycle poets did not.
The poet's task is to describe not what has happened but what could happen — what is probable or necessary. Poetry is more philosophical than history.
Simple and complex plots. Complex plots involve reversal (peripeteia) and recognition (anagnorisis). The best combine both.
The parts of a plot: reversal, recognition, and suffering. Reversal is a change to the opposite; recognition is a change from ignorance to knowledge.
The quantitative parts of tragedy: prologue, episode, exode, and choral parts (parode and stasimon).
The tragic hero. He should be neither perfectly good nor completely wicked, but a good man who falls through hamartia — an error of judgement.
Pity and fear. The best tragedies arouse these through the plot itself, not through spectacle. The Oedipus is the model.
Character in tragedy. The four requirements: characters should be good, appropriate, lifelike, and consistent.
Recognition scenes. Six types, from the crudest (tokens and birthmarks) to the best (arising naturally from the events of the plot).
Practical advice for poets. Visualise the action on stage. Work out the general structure before filling in the episodes.
Complication and resolution. Every tragedy has a complication (the tying of the knot) and a resolution (the untying). The deus ex machina should be avoided.
Types of tragedy: complex, pathetic, ethical, and spectacular. The best combine reversal and recognition.
The chorus should be treated as one of the actors. Its songs should be integral to the plot, not mere interludes.
Thought and diction. How characters argue, prove, and express emotion. The verbal element of tragedy.
Diction continued. Parts of speech, metaphor, and poetic language. Metaphor is the mark of genius — it cannot be taught.
Further analysis of diction. Standard, exotic, and ornamental language. The ideal style is clear but not commonplace.
Epic poetry. Its similarities to and differences from tragedy. Epic uses narrative rather than dramatic form and has a different scale.
Problems of criticism and their solutions. How to answer objections to Homer and the tragedians. Tragedy is superior to epic as an art form.